Krystal Scurry
February 1989 - November
2, 1991
On January 26, 1990, a family
member of Theresa Tyler called the Aiken
County Department Of Social
Services to help because there was no electricity
in the home. Ruby Chambliss
and Louise Blount showed up at their home and
found Krystal Scurry and
her halfbrother, Debarge Staley, were sick with colds
and their mother had the
flu. Rather than help them, the women took action
to remove the children from
the home.
Theresa objected to her children
being taken from them and so did Jessie Scurry, Krystal's father who told
the women:
"I ain`t signing nothing.
I ain`t giving my kids to nobody"
The women told them that if
they didn't cooperate, the police would be called.
The children were taken and
in their report, they said the trailer was cold,
smelled of urine and milk
had gone bad and they had tried to contact Police
who were unavailable at that
time. The two children had never had shots nor
had they been seen by a doctor,
since their births. Krystal, who was 11 months old and Debarge, who was
three years old, were placed in the foster home of
Clarissa Bell Bates.
For about a year, the children
saw their parents rarely and their social worker
was also scarce. Their parents
would say that the department did little to help
reunite them with their children
and the department would claim that the their
parents had made no effort
to see them.
While the children were in
her care, Debarge said that Clarissa shook him
violently, slapped him, yanked
on him, forced food into his mouth and made
him sleep on the floor. Debarge
said that worse was done to his sister. Stacy
Brown, another foster child
who was 19 years old and one of the six foster
children who lived there,
backed Debarge up on his claims:
"She'd get mad
when Krystal wouldn't eat. Sometimes she'd
do it until Krystal
would vomit. It was bad; she was so tiny"
This wouldn't prove to be
the worst thing that Clarissa was doing.
Mary Craft, a child services
coordinator with the support group, Babynet, said
that the signs of abuse were
obvious. Krystal was 22 months old and at that
time she was just starting
to walk and she couldn't talk very well. One of her
arms hung down by her side
and she wouldn't allow anyone to touch it in
order to check it. A knot
could be seen on her forehead. Mary reported what
she had seen to the the Department
Of Social Services on more than one
occasion. She would later
state that five different names were given to her for
social workers. None of them
knew anything about Krystal at all and they all
would say:
"It's not my case. It's
not my case"
Mary said when she finally
did get ahold of the real caseworker, he said he had just took over the
case and didn't know much about it.
On February 15, 1991, Clarissa
took Krystal, Debarge and two other children
to the Aiken Community Hospital.
A hospital social worker made a report that
said Clarissa had pinched
one of the children on the buttocks, grabbed one of
the children by the throat
and Clarissa had left without anyone having treated
Krystal. Clarissa then took
Krystal to the Medical College Of Georgia where Dr.
Rebecca Jean Atha admitted
her and kept her there for almost two weeks. Dr.
Atha would later say that
she kept her there because she was afraid to send
her back to the foster home.
Krystal seemed depressed for
a two year and had a paralysis on her right side
that could not be explained
and she had a broken arm. She was suffering from two healing leg fractures.
Dr. Atha said that she had called the Department
several times and had talked
to Bill Perkins, the caseworker:
"I told him that I was
very afraid for this child, that I did
not think she should
go back to this foster home"
Dr. Atha said that Bill told
her he understood what she was saying and that he
was going to take full responsibility
for Krystal. Bill was going to put her into
the best foster home he knew
of, that would be the home of Clarissa, which
was where Krystal had been
injured in the first place.
Eventually, Clarissa's son,
John Bell, who was 44 at that time, moved into the
home with them. He was a
transient and and ex-convict. Debarge told the
people at DSS that he didn't
like John, that John had kicked him in his belly,
hit him with a belt and also
hit him in the head with a hammer. Debarge also
told them that John had kicked
Krystal and two of the other children living in
the house and that Clarissa
had known about it.
On November 2, 1991, John
took Krystal and left the home in the car. Four
days later, Krystal's naked
and bruised body was found in the woods outside
of Aiken. Workers who were
gathering pine straw for bailing, found her. John
Bell admitted that he had
been smoking crack cocaine on the day of her
murder. He was prosecuted
and sentenced to 30 years for the rape and killing
of Krystal. What a ridiculous
sentence!
After her death, the extent
of the injuries that Krystal had suffered at the hands of Clarissa were
finally out in the open. In November of 1993, Clarissa was
arrested and charged with
multiple offenses including assault and battery as
well as physical and medical
neglect. The postmortem x-rays revealed that she
had fractures to her right
shoulder, both of her knees and her right pubic
bone. By the time she died,
Krystal was partially paralyzed and she could no
longer walk at all.
Barbara Morgan, a Solicitor
of Aiken said that she didn't know how to describe
the foster home other than
to say it was a hellhole where a child was tortured
for over 20 months and had
almost every major joint in her body, broken. The DSS workers who took
these children from their mother, simply because they
had colds, placed her with
the foster parent and then either didn't notice that
the children were being abused
or they did notice and they chose to ignore it
and refused to provide protection.
In December of 1993, the two
caseworkers who had removed the children,
Ruby and Louise were arrested.
Ruby, who was the supervisor of the county
child protective services
unit, was charged with illegally using DSS control over the children when
she removed them. Also among her charges was her failure
to investigate the neglect
allegations against the parents of the children, ill
treatment of a child and
failure to perform her state mandated child protective
duties.
Louis, the supervisor of the
county treatment unit, was charged with illegally
removing the children by
forcing the parents to voluntarily place the children
in the custody of DSS. The
two caseworkers were also charged with illegally
taking $50. from Krystal's
father. The money was given to pay for the medical
care of the children, the
two women used for themselves instead.
For what these two disgusting
women did to this family, they were suspended
with pay, in December of
1993. Their suspensions were to remain in affect
until the outcome of the
proceedings. They enjoyed their paid vacations until
they returned back to work
in May of 1994. The charges were still pending
against them. They both worked
desk jobs until in February of 1995, they
were both let go due to falsifying
the records in the case. They had reported
that it was snowing and that
the house was cold due to a lack of heat. It was
later learned that it had
actually been warm outside that day.
The two child protective workers
most responsible for Krystal's tragic death would be suspended, with pay,
in December of 1993 pending the outcome of the proceedings. Ruby Chambliss
and Louise Blount would enjoy their paid vacation until the Department
would call them back to work in May of 1994, with the charges still pending
against them in court. In all, six social workers,
that included the director
of foster care, would be charged in connection with
the death of Krystal. The
charges included ethics violations, falsification of
records, embezzlement and
neglect of duties.
"The whole system killed
Krystal. If they hadn't took her from me, she'd still be with me now. I
know she'd be safe when she was with me, and I wouldn't let nobody harm
her"
Theresa Tyler
A settlement with the Aiken
County Department Of Social Services was settled
and Krystal's parents received
$467,000., not nearly enough to compensate for what they lost. Between
February 1991 and January of 1992, there were
five foster children killed
in South Carolina.
Clarissa Bell bates was charged
with assault and battery of a high, medical
neglect for failing to get
medical attention from May of 1990 to November of
1990, for Krystal, after
a doctor told her to. Physical neglect charges from
February 1991 to November
1991 and failure to provide nutrition. Records
show that Krystal's weight
went up and down and right before her death, she
only weight 22 pounds 3 ounces.
Charges against the Social
Workers, other than Ruby and Louise included:
Cassie Scott Wilson, who supervised
the caseworkers in charge of Krystal,
unlawful neglect, 23 counts
of embezzling funds set aside for 13 foster care
children. Reports say that
Cassie took over $9,000., spending about $6,000.
for her own personal use.
Marie A. Moore, the former
director of foster care was charged with ill treat-
ment and unlawful neglect
of a child and failure to report child abuse.
Clarence H. Graham and William
Perkins were also charged. William had been
the caseworker who was called
by the Dr. at the hospital and ignored her
warnings and placed Krystal
back in the foster home.
This case seems to stop here.
Repeated attempts made by me, to find out
what the final outcome was,
to find out what people were prosecuted for and
what sentences were handed
down, have been unsuccessful. This case seems
to have dropped from sight.
For information about preventing
child abuse in the state of South Carolina, click the links below. If they
can't help you, ask for someone who can. NEVER give up looking for
help for an abused child!

|