Jordan Desmond
Heikamp
May 19, 1999 - June 23, 1997
Renee Heikamp was a new mother
and she was homeless when the Catholic
Children's Aid society placed
them in the Anduhyaun Shelter for abused aboriginal women, in Canada. At
that time, Jordan's weight at the time he and
his mother entered the shelter
was four pounds six ounces. weeks later when
he died, he weighed four
pounds two ounces.
Angie Martin was the caseworker
assigned to Renee and Jordan. Renee would
tell Angie that Jordan was
gaining weight and doing fine, it was a lie. Why is it
that Angie wasn't there to
SEE
what was going on?
Workers at the shelter claimed
that Renee was more interested in talking on
the phone than in being a
mother to Jordan. They called Angie and made her
aware of what was going on.
Renee said that she was feeding
Jordan every two to four hours and that he
ate like a pig, when she
was interviewed by police after he died, she would say that it was hard
to feed him because he was always falling asleep while eating and that
he slept for up to eight hours at a time. This statement didn't make
sense to the people at the
shelter:
"Well that just indicates
a complete lack of common sense.
I mean, she also understood,
and she also testified she knew,
she had to feed the
baby every two to three hours,"
Susan Hare Lawyer for
Anduhyaun
Pictures that were shown at
trial were of a baby who was nothing but skin and
bones. Jordan's skeleton
could be seen from the outside with a little bit of skin
hanging off of it. The coroner
asked Renee why it was that her soon looked like he did and she did nothing
to help him. Renee started crying and insisted that it was not how he looked
before he died or she would have taken him to the hospital. A pediatrician
testified that the pictures showed how Jordan would have looked in the
last two or three days of his life. Renee also said that
there were no signs of Jordan
was starving to death before he died.
Renee said that the staff
at the shelter had told her that babies grew while they
were sleeping and she should
not wake him up to feed him. Stating that she
was happy with the shelter
when she first arrived, she later felt that she was
being ignored and that they
didn't want her there, she felt uncomfortable after
being there for awhile.
Angie Martin only saw Jordan
twice after being assigned as their case worker.
She saw him once after he
left the hospital and once, two weeks before his
death. Angie chose to hold
interviews with Renee in her office and at one
point even suggested to her
that she get a baby sitter to watch Jordan while
she attended the interviews.
When she saw Jordan, Angie wrote in her notes
that it didn't seem he was
gaining weight, however, she didn't act on this.
Angie claimed to be overwork,
saying she had 38 cases. A review of her files
would later show that most
of those cases were either closed or inactive. One of the saddest revelations
is that if Renee and Jordan had been living in a place of their own, she
would probably have had more visits from Angie. Angie had assumed that
the shelter was monitoring Jordan's progress though legally he was the
responsibility of her and the Catholic Children's Aid Society.
When asked why she had lied
to Angie Martin about his weight gain, Renee said that a lack of education
on her part was partly to blame for Jordan's death, just she didn't know
how sick he really was. Placing part of the blame on Angie Martin, she
said that there was a lack of assistance and she should have taken more
responsibility. She would later say that she realized it was hard on Angie
Martin because she made it difficult for her to give her the help she needed.
Renee Heikamp and Angie
Martin were charged with criminal negligence
resulting in death. In 1998
after the preliminary hearing which lasted 13 days,
Madam Justice Mary Hogan
of the Ontario Court Of Justice ruled that Jordan's
case would not go to trial
due to lack of evidence. Mary Hogan ruled that the
evidence of wanton reckless
disregard for the life of and safety of another
person by either Renee or
Angie, was not proven. The judge also ruled that
death of Jordan was a terrible
tragedy which could have been prevented:
"The difficulty here
seemed to be that everyone felt that
somebody else was taking
responsibility with the result t
hat no one took full
responsibility"
Crown counsel Paul Culver
felt that Judge Hogan had made a mistake and that
if she had then a preliminary
hearing as she should have, she could have made the findings credible:
"The Crown could still
have sought a preferred indictment which,
if successful, would
have sent the two women directly to trial"
However, he felt that a trial
of that nature could taken three years to actually
happen. They could not force
Renee to testify and if she did, the jury might
not find her guilty since
she was a teenage mother and if she were to be
convicted, how much time
would she receive? He also felt that the jury would
be unwilling to convict a
middle aged case worker. Paul Culver decided that
an inquest was needed.
A coroners inquest is presided
over by a medical doctor and is much like a
trial since witnesses are
called, though nothing they say can be used against
them. The jury does not find
blame in what has happened, they are only able
to make recommendations to
improve the system.
In April 2001, a four month
investigation was concluded and a coroner's
inquest ruled the death of
Jordan to be a homicide and recommended changes
be made to the child protection
system to prevent deaths of children in the
future. Implicated in the
recommendations were the entire child protection
system including the Catholic
Children's Aid Society, homeless shelters, public
health departments, hospitals
and the Ministry Of Community And Social
Services.
The Ontario coroner's office
made 44 recommendations for changes to protect children, including the
following:
That child protection workers
realize that their client is the child in need of protection, not the parent.
That children's aid workers
hold weekly face-to-face home visits with children under four months.
That child protection workers
be made aware that some young people in the shelter system have become
adept at lying and manipulation.
That shelter staff offer help
without being asked.
That shelter workers be educated
to recognize the signs of when a baby is not thriving.
That the time for children's
aid workers to assess the risks of newborns be shortened to seven days
from 21.
That there be an increase
in funding to supervising agencies.
That new prenatal programs
be establish for teens and homeless mothers.
When the verdict was read,
Renee cried. She said that the recommendations
proved she was not solely
responsible for the death of Jordan:
"I hope something positive
comes out of all this
and other young mothers
learn from all this."

For information about preventing
child abuse in the Canada, click the links below. If they can't help you,
ask for someone who can. NEVER give up looking for help for an abused
child!
Child
Abuse Prevention Resources
Prevent
Child Abuse In Canada
|